Delayed Final Payday Rule

On June 6, 2019, the CFPB issued the latest final Payday Lending Rule formally delaying the compliance dates for the mandatory underwriting provisions and making technical corrections to the payment provisions of the original Rule.  The compliance dates are set out in a new section, §1041.15, of the Rule.  The Executive Summary notes that the Bureau “continues to consider comments related to the proposal to rescind the Mandatory Underwriting Provisions.”  The Bureau also published an unofficial redline of the Rule highlighting the changes in the text and commentary of the Rule.

January 16, 2018 – Effective date of the Rule.

April 16, 2018 – Application deadline for registered information systems. [§1041.11(c)(1)] This does not affect financial institutions.  This applies to credit bureau requirements for receiving and reporting payday loan records.

August 19, 2019 – The compliance date for payment requirements Prohibited payment transfer attempts [§1041.8], Disclosure of payment transfer attempts [§1041.9], along with Definitions [§1041.2], Scope of coverage; exclusions; exemptions [§1041.3], Identification of unfair and abusive practice [1041.7], sections not relating to consumer reports of Compliance program and record retention  [1041.12(a), (b) introductory text], (b)(4), and (b)(5)], and Prohibition against evasion [1041.13].

November 19, 2020 – The compliance date for underwriting requirements, Identification of unfair and abusive practice [§1041.4], Ability-to-repay determination required [§1041.5], Conditional exemption for certain covered short-term loans [1041.6], Information furnishing requirements [§1041.10], sections relating to consumer reports of Compliance program and record retention [§1041.12(b)(1) – (3)].

In order to be ready for August 19, institutions will need to ensure they will be able to comply with the payment requirements, including the notification of payment transfer attempts, the prohibition of transfers after two failed payment transfer attempts and the consumer rights notice.  Institutions must also have written policies and procedures to ensure compliance with the Rule and update their retention policies to include the Rule’s requirements.

Coverage

The Payday Lending Rule applies to three types of loans (covered loans) extended to a consumer for personal, family, or household use.  These, generally, are:

  1. Covered short term loans that require repayment within 45 days of consummation or an advance – regardless of the cost of credit;
  2. Covered longer-term loans that have certain types of balloon-payment structures – regardless of the cost of credit; and
  3. Covered longer-term loans that have a cost of credit exceeding 36% APR and have a leveraged payment mechanism giving the lender the right to initiate transfers from the consumer’s account without further action by the consumer.

A leveraged payment mechanism is when a lender or service provider obtains a right to initiate a transfer or money, through any means, from a consumer’s account to satisfy an obligation on a loan.  This can include the right to initiate a transfer from a consumer’s account by means of a check, an electronic fund transfer, a remotely created check or payment order, or a transfer by an account-holding institution.

Exclusions

Not included in the Rule’s requirements are:

  1. Alternative loans, which are loans that generally conform to the NCUA’s requirements for the PAL program regardless of whether the lender is a federally insured credit union;
  2. Accommodation loans, provided the lender together with its affiliates do not originate more than 2500 covered loans in a calendar year and did not derive more than 10 percent of their receipts from covered loans during the previous tax year.
  3. Purchase money security interest loan, when the credit is extended solely and expressly for the purpose of financing a consumer’s initial purchase of a good, and the credit is secured by that good.
  4. Real estate secured credit, where the credit is secured by any real property or by personal property that is used as a dwelling.
  5. Credit card accounts, as defined by Regulation Z.
  6. Student loans, authorized by the Higher Education Act or private education loans as defined by Regulation Z.
  7. Non-recourse pawn loan, if the lender has sole physical possession and use of the property securing the loan for the entire loan term, and the lender’s sole recourse is the retention of that property.
  8. Overdraft service; overdraft line of credit, as defined by Regulation E.
  9. Wage advance program, made by an employer to an employee only on accrued, unpaid, wages.
  10. No cost advance, where no fee or charge is assessed, and the lender warrants that there is no legal claim based on failure to repay, no collection activities will occur, and the loan will not be reported to the credit bureaus.

Disclosure of Payment Transfer Attempts

There are three types of disclosures required relating to payment transfers initiated in connection with a covered loan:

  1. First payment withdrawal notice. A lender must provide a first payment withdrawal notice to a consumer in advance of initiating the first payment withdrawal from a consumer’s account.
  2. Unusual payment withdrawal notice. A lender must provide an unusual payment withdrawal notice in advance of initiating an unusual payment withdrawal from the consumer’s account.
  3. Consumer rights notice. A lender must provide a consumer rights notice to a consumer if a lender has initiated two consecutive failed payment transfers from a consumer’s account.

These notices may be provided electronically if the lender obtains consent in accordance with the Rule.  E-Sign consent is not required.  When delivering the notices electronically through certain deliver methods, such as text messaging, a lender is required to provide a short notice to the consumer.  Use of the Bureau’s model forms provides a safe harbor for the institution.

Prohibited Payment Transfer Attempts

“Payment transfer” means a debit or withdrawal of funds from a consumer’s account that the lender initiates for the purpose of collecting any amount due or purported to be due in connection with a covered loan. A debit or withdrawal meeting this description is a payment transfer regardless of the means the lender uses to initiate it. For example, a payment transfer includes, but is not limited to, a debit or withdrawal initiated by an electronic fund transfer (such as a debit card, prepaid card, or ACH transfer), a signature check, a remotely created check, and a remotely created payment order.

The Rule provides for a conditional exclusion for prohibited payment transfers for lenders that are also the account-holding institution.  Unless the Rule’s conditional exclusion applies, a lender that is also the account-holding institution initiates a payment transfer if it does any of the following:

  1. Initiates an internal transfer from a consumer’s account to collect a payment on a covered loan;
  2. Sweeps a consumer’s account in response to a delinquency on a covered loan; or
  3. Exercises a right to set off or offset in order to collect an outstanding balance on a covered loan.

The conditional exclusion for account holding institutions applies when the lender does not charge a fee when the transfer account lacks sufficient funds for the transfer (e.g. overdraft, NSF, returned items) and the lender does not close the consumer’s account in response to a negative balance relating to the transfer.  Note – that for the conditional exclusion to apply, both of these provisions must be spelled out in the loan or account agreement.

Generally, a lender is prohibited from initiating payment transfers after the lender has attempted two consecutive failed payment transfer attempts in relation to any covered loan the consumer has with the lender.

A first failed payment transfer occurs if it meets any of the following:

  1. The lender has initiated no other payment transfers from the account in connection with the covered loan or any other covered loan that the consumer has with the lender;
  2. The immediately preceding payment transfer was successful, regardless of whether the lender has previously initiated a first failed payment transfer; or
  3. The payment transfer is the first payment transfer to fail after the lender obtains the consumer’s new and specific authorization for additional payment transfers

A second failed payment transfer occurs when a second attempt follows the immediately preceding failed payment transfer, including an attempt initiated at the same time or the same day.

After two failed payment transfer attempts, the lender must obtain new authorization from the consumer before attempting any additional transfers.

Compliance Program and Record Retention

A lender must have written policies and procedures designed to reasonably comply with the Payday Lending Rule.

A lender must retain evidence of compliance with the Payday Lending Rule for 36 months after a loan is no longer outstanding.

For each covered loan, the lender must retain or be able to reproduce an image of the following documentation, as applicable:

  1. Leveraged payment mechanisms the lender obtained from the consumer,
  2. Authorizations of additional payment transfers, and
  3. Underlying one-time electronic transaction authorizations or underlying signature checks.

And, the lender must retain electronic records in tabular format of the history of payments received and attempted payment transfers.  This must include:

  • The date of receipt of the payment or attempted payment transfer,
  • The amount of the payment due,
  • The amount of the attempted payment transfer,
  • The amount of the payment received or transferred, and
  • The payment channel used for an attempted payment transfer.

Law-Related Services Disclaimer.  Please be advised, CSG provides financial services compliance audit and consulting services to our clients.  The services that we provide include certain tasks that may be characterized as “law-related services” under Rule 5.7 of the Rules of Professional Conduct governing lawyers.  Since some of our employees are lawyers with an active bar license but are NOT engaged in the private practice of law, that Rule requires us to make disclosures clarifying that the services we perform may be law-related services, but they are not legal services.  Because they are not legal services, those services and our relationship will not be governed by the Rules of Professional Conduct that guide the client-lawyer relationship, such as rules applicable to privileged communications and prohibitions of conflicts of interest.  Notwithstanding this disclaimer, we will continue to govern our relationship with you using reasonable ethical and professional standards that are expected to meet your expectations

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *